New York City has a long and rich history of underground poker games. While Las Vegas and Atlantic City are known for their legal casino poker, NYC has always had a thriving scene of underground poker clubs. Here’s a look at how it evolved:
Early Days of NYC Underground Poker Clubs
In the early 1900s, poker was commonly played in backrooms of bars and speakeasies, especially during Prohibition. The game was associated with organized crime and was often played in illegal gambling houses.
The Boom of Underground Poker Clubs in the 1980s and 1990s
By the late 20th century, underground poker clubs began to flourish in NYC. These clubs were typically located in hidden venues, from apartments to basements of restaurants. Many of them operated under the radar, with some becoming well-known among high-stakes players.
One of the most famous underground poker clubs during this era was the Mayfair Club, where legendary players like Erik Seidel and Howard Lederer honed their skills. The Mayfair Club was known for its high-level strategy and professionalism, paving the way for many poker legends.
The Rise and Fall of the NYC Underground Poker Club Scene
As poker gained mainstream popularity in the early 2000s—thanks in part to televised poker events and online poker—underground poker clubs in NYC also saw a rise in activity. However, law enforcement crackdowns in the mid-2000s led to the shutdown of many of these clubs, including famous spots like the Diamond Club and New York Players Club.
Despite these crackdowns, underground poker clubs continue to thrive in NYC, albeit in a more discreet fashion. Today’s private clubs operate with tighter security measures, vetting processes, and sometimes membership fees to ensure the safety and integrity of their games.
Are Underground Poker Club Membership Fees Worth It?
For players looking to join an underground poker club, understanding the membership fee structure is crucial. Some benefits of paying a membership fee include:
- Better security and vetting – Ensures that only serious players join.
- Higher quality games – Discourages casual drop-ins and maintains a consistent player pool.
- Added amenities – Some clubs offer complimentary drinks, food, or private dealers.
However, for casual players or those who prefer flexibility, a no-membership-fee club with a pay-to-play model might be the best choice.
While not all underground poker clubs require membership fees, many do to maintain exclusivity, cover operational costs, and ensure game integrity. Whether through a monthly subscription, one-time initiation fee, or rake-based model, underground poker clubs offer a variety of ways for players to participate. Understanding these structures can help poker enthusiasts make informed decisions about where to play. In cities like NYC, where underground poker clubs have a storied history, these clubs continue to serve as a hub for serious and recreational players alike.
